Beauty Brands Are Dropping Talc. The FDA Dropped Its Asbestos Testing Rule First.

Talc-free has become one of the most visible reformulation trends in beauty. NBC News reported on October 19, 2026, that brands are reworking bestselling powders and color cosmetics without talc. The experts it interviewed described the shift as a response to consumer trust and regulation, not to settled evidence that talc harms skin.
What that coverage only touches on is the regulatory gap underneath the trend. Congress ordered the FDA to set a federal standard for testing talc-containing cosmetics for asbestos. The FDA proposed one in December 2024. It withdrew that proposal on November 28, 2025. As of this writing, no replacement has been published.
That leaves brands that still use talc, and brands replacing it, making safety decisions without a federal testing method to point to.
There is no federal asbestos testing standard for talc in cosmetics right now. Your safety substantiation obligation did not wait for one.
What Congress Required and What the FDA Withdrew
Section 3505 of the Modernization of Cosmetics Regulation Act of 2022 (MoCRA) requires the FDA to issue proposed and final regulations establishing and requiring standardized testing methods for detecting and identifying asbestos in talc-containing cosmetic products.
The FDA's proposed rule, published December 27, 2024, at 89 FR 105490, would have required testing of talc-containing cosmetics or the talc used in them, along with records demonstrating compliance. A product that did not meet those requirements would have been deemed adulterated.
The withdrawal notice, published at 90 FR 54603 under Docket No. FDA-2023-N-4225, said the FDA received 49 comments and pointed to three areas of concern:
• Scope. Commenters warned of unintended consequences for products regulated as both cosmetics and drugs, and for other consumer products made with talc.
• Science. The agency cited the complexity of asbestos testing itself.
• Legal authority. The FDA cited legal considerations under the Administrative Procedure Act, including comments questioning its authority to treat a cosmetic as adulterated based on any amount of asbestos.
The FDA stated that it will issue a new proposed rule to meet its MoCRA obligation. It has not said when it will issue a new proposal or how it would differ from the one it withdrew.
What the FDA's Own Testing Shows
The FDA has tested talc-containing cosmetics for asbestos through a contract laboratory, AMA Analytical Services, using polarized light microscopy and transmission electron microscopy. The record is more nuanced than either side of the talc debate usually admits.
Testing Round | What the FDA Tested | Result |
2009-2010 survey | Cosmetic-grade raw talc and finished products | No asbestos found, but only four of nine talc suppliers submitted samples, and the FDA said the results did not prove the market was asbestos-free |
2019 sampling assignment | 52 talc-containing products, including some already reported by third parties as contaminated | 9 positive; recalls followed, and the FDA cautioned that the rate did not reflect the overall market |
2022 sampling assignment | 50 products, including products popular on social media and products marketed to children | No asbestos detected |
2023 sampling assignment | 50 products selected on similar criteria | No asbestos detected |
Recent federal sampling has come back clean. But the FDA's own description of the 2009-2010 survey is the more useful lesson for brand owners: a clean survey is informative, not proof. The agency's talc page explains that talc and asbestos can form close together in the earth, which is why talc mining sites must be selected carefully and the ore tested sufficiently.
Consumer pressure is coming from outside the FDA as well. As NBC News noted, the World Health Organization's cancer research agency classified talc as probably carcinogenic in 2024, citing limited evidence for ovarian cancer, and years of asbestos litigation have kept the ingredient in the headlines.
Why the Missing Rule Does Not Lower Your Obligations
MoCRA made the responsible person, meaning the manufacturer, packer, or distributor whose name appears on the label, responsible for ensuring and maintaining records that support adequate substantiation of each product's safety. That duty applies whether or not the FDA has defined a testing method.
The consequences of getting it wrong are also larger than they were before MoCRA. The FDA now receives mandatory serious adverse event reports, can access certain records, and holds mandatory recall authority over cosmetics. If asbestos turned up in a talc-containing product, the first question would not be whether you used the FDA's method. It would be which method you used, how often, on which lots, and where the records are.
Without a federal method, the testing standard defaults to whatever you can defend. Choose it deliberately and write it down.
Reformulating Away From Talc Is a Regulatory Event, Too
Removing talc does not end the analysis. It starts a new one.
• Update your product listing. A reformulation changes the ingredient list you submitted to the FDA. MoCRA requires product listings to be updated annually, so make sure the new formula is captured.
• Qualify the replacement. The ingredients that take over talc's absorbent and texturizing roles come from their own supply chains, with their own sourcing and contaminant questions. Supplier qualification and specifications have to be built for the new ingredient, not carried over.
• Re-substantiate safety. A new formula needs its own safety substantiation. The talc version's file does not transfer.
• Watch your claims. A talc-free claim must be accurate for every SKU and lot. Statements implying that talc products are unsafe, or that your product is asbestos-free, need substantiation you can produce on request.
• Manage the transition. If talc and talc-free versions are on shelves at the same time, labels, listings, and marketing have to distinguish them clearly.
What Beauty Brands Should Do Now
• Inventory every talc-containing product. Include private label and contract-manufactured SKUs, and identify each talc supplier and, where possible, the mine source.
• Adopt a written asbestos testing protocol. Define the method, the testing frequency, whether you test raw talc, finished product, or both, and the laboratory you use. The FDA's own sampling relied on both polarized light microscopy and transmission electron microscopy, and the agency has described TEM as the most sensitive method for detecting and quantifying asbestos minerals.
• Ask for data, not just certificates. Request the underlying results behind any certificate of analysis and confirm the laboratory's accreditation.
• Keep the file ready. Assume your testing records and safety substantiation will be read by the FDA, a retailer, or opposing counsel, and organize them accordingly.
• Treat reformulation as a compliance project. If you reformulate, complete the listing, substantiation, and claims steps above before launch, not after.
• Prepare to comment. When the FDA issues a new proposed rule under MoCRA section 3505, there will be a comment period. Brands that already run a protocol will be best placed to explain what is workable.
How Bustos Law Group Helps Beauty Brands Stay Compliant
Bustos Law Group works with cosmetic and beauty brands nationwide on FDA compliance, MoCRA implementation, and the evolving enforcement landscape. The firm provides safety substantiation audits, supplier and contract manufacturer agreement reviews, product listing reviews, label and claims assessments, recall planning, and Warning Letter response strategy.
Whether you keep talc or reformulate away from it, the decision should be documented in a way that holds up when the FDA, a retailer, or a plaintiff asks how you made it.
Schedule a consultation with Bustos Law Group to review your talc testing protocol and safety substantiation files.
Sources: U.S. Food and Drug Administration (FDA.gov) | Federal Register | NBC News
This blog is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For guidance specific to your business, contact Bustos Law Group.



Comments