California Joins New York: Your Marketing Now Decides Who Can Buy Your Supplement

On September 28, 2026, California Governor Gavin Newsom signed Assembly Bill 2030, which prohibits selling over-the-counter diet pills and dietary supplements for weight loss or muscle building to anyone under 18. On October 6, the Council for Responsible Nutrition (CRN) announced that the U.S. Supreme Court had declined to hear its challenge to New York's version of the same law.
New York's law has been in force since April 2024. California's takes effect January 1, 2027. If you sell weight management, sports nutrition, or performance products nationally, two of the largest consumer markets in the country will soon require age verification for those products, and the federal courts have so far declined to stop either one.
The part brand owners most need to understand is how a product ends up covered. It is not only what is in the bottle. It is how the product is labeled, marketed, and even shelved.
Under these laws, a supplement is a weight loss or muscle building product if it is labeled, marketed, or otherwise represented that way. Your copywriting is now part of your compliance program.
How New York Decides What Is Covered
New York General Business Law section 391-oo covers dietary supplements that are labeled, marketed, or otherwise represented for the purpose of achieving weight loss or muscle building. Protein powders, protein drinks, and protein foods are excluded unless they contain another ingredient that would, on its own, make the product covered.
The statute then lists factors a court must consider in deciding whether a product is covered:
• Whether the product contains an FDA-approved weight loss or muscle building ingredient, a steroid, or any of five named ingredients: creatine, green tea extract, raspberry ketone, garcinia cambogia, or green coffee bean extract.
• Whether its labeling or marketing uses statements or images that express or imply it will help modify, maintain, or reduce body weight, fat, appetite, overall metabolism, or how nutrients are metabolized, or help maintain or increase muscle or strength.
• Whether the product or its ingredients are otherwise represented for weight loss or muscle building.
• Whether the retailer has categorized it that way, through signs or tags, or by grouping it with weight loss or muscle building products in a display, advertisement, webpage, or area of the store.
That last factor surprises brands. A retailer's decision to place your product in a weight management category can count toward coverage, whatever your own label says. And because these are factors rather than a checklist, a creatine or green tea extract product with no weight or muscle claim on its label is not automatically outside the law.
What Compliance Looks Like at Checkout
In New York, retail establishments must require proof of age, such as a driver's license, passport, or military ID. A seller may skip the ID check for a buyer who reasonably appears to be at least 25, but that appearance is not a defense if the buyer turns out to be a minor. Delivery sellers, including online retailers, must ship using a method that requires an adult to sign for the package and show government-issued photo identification proving they are at least 18.
The New York Attorney General enforces the law through injunction proceedings, and a court may impose a civil penalty of up to $500 for a violation. Misusing data captured from ID scans carries a separate civil penalty of up to $1,000 per violation.
California's AB 2030 follows the same architecture, including similar factors for deciding whether a product is covered, and adds a stricter verification step for online sales:
Requirement | New York (GBL Section 391-oo) | California (AB 2030) |
Status | In effect since April 2024 | Signed September 28, 2026; effective January 1, 2027 |
Covered products | OTC diet pills and supplements labeled, marketed, or represented for weight loss or muscle building | Same core definition, with similar coverage factors |
In-store sales | Proof of age required; ID check may be skipped only for buyers who reasonably appear 25 or older | Valid ID requested from buyers who appear to be under 18; retailers may restrict access to covered products |
Online and delivery sales | Adult signature and photo ID at delivery | Purchaser's name, date of birth, and address verified against a commercial database of government-sourced records, plus adult signature and photo ID at delivery |
What the Supreme Court Did, and Did Not, Decide
CRN had asked the Supreme Court to review a Second Circuit decision affirming the denial of a preliminary injunction against New York's law. CRN's position is that the statute casts too wide a net, restricts commercial speech based on its content, and reaches lawful products that New York has not shown cause the harms it cites.
The denial is not a ruling that the law is constitutional. It means the law stays in effect while the case continues in district court. For planning purposes, that distinction matters less than it sounds. Brands should assume New York's law will be enforced and California's will take effect on schedule.
This Is Becoming a Patchwork
Governor Newsom's office justified California's law by pointing to research findings that nearly 1 in 10 adolescents have used weight loss or muscle-building products, and to the risk that such products are mislabeled or tainted with substances like steroids. Similar bills have been introduced in other states, including New Jersey.
A national brand cannot run a different compliance program for every state. The practical answer is to design one program around the strictest requirements in force and apply it wherever you ship covered products, or to stop shipping covered products to states where you cannot meet the requirements.
If your product page talks about metabolism, fat burning, appetite, lean muscle, or strength, assume the product is covered and build your checkout accordingly.
What Supplement Brands Should Do Now
• Classify your portfolio against the statutory factors. Review every SKU for the named ingredients, for weight, fat, appetite, metabolism, muscle, or strength language, and for how it is categorized on your site and by your retailers. Do this product by product, not brand by brand.
• Audit your marketing, not just your labels. Website copy, marketplace titles and bullets, influencer scripts, ad creative, and images all count. If you want a product to fall outside these laws, everything said about it has to support that position.
• Talk to your retail and marketplace partners. Their category placement can be weighed against you. Agree in writing on how covered and non-covered products will be categorized and who performs age verification.
• Fix direct-to-consumer checkout and fulfillment before January 1. Confirm that your ecommerce platform and carrier can perform California's database verification and adult signature with photo ID for California addresses, and that your New York process already does what the statute requires.
• Revisit your contracts. Distribution, fulfillment, and marketplace agreements should allocate responsibility for age verification and include indemnification for sales to minors.
• Track the states. Assign someone to monitor new age-restriction bills. The definitions and verification methods are similar, but not identical, from state to state.
How Bustos Law Group Protects Supplement Brands
Bustos Law Group provides comprehensive FDA legal services for dietary supplement brands nationwide, including label and marketing claim reviews, state law compliance assessments, contract drafting and negotiation, Warning Letter response strategy, and recall management.
With a 95% Warning Letter resolution rate and a dedicated team of food and supplement experts, the firm helps brands build compliance programs that hold up under both federal and state requirements.
California's law takes effect January 1, 2027. Schedule a consultation with Bustos Law Group to classify your portfolio and review your marketing and checkout process before then.
Sources: New York State Senate (nysenate.gov) | Office of the Governor of California (gov.ca.gov) | California State Senate Judiciary Committee | Council for Responsible Nutrition
This blog is for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. For guidance specific to your business, contact Bustos Law Group.



Comments